Only One Story

Fans of Robert Jordan’s Wheel of Time series often complain about or even refuse to read the Sword of Truth series by Terry Goodkind.  They claim that it is too similar, that Goodkind ripped off the idea.  It is true that you can summarize the basic plot for the entirety of each series in the same way.  “Young male protagonist grows up without magic, is sent on a task that exposes him to a larger world, which leads to the development of his latent magic abilities and the discovery that he is destined to fight a malevolent magic practitioner to save the world.”

Okay, so there is a similar story concept at work.  However, all it takes is reading past the first novel of both series to figure out that the basic structure is used in dramatically different fashion by each author.  (In fact, this seems to be a prevalent plot pattern in fantasy.  Re-read that summary sentence.  It sounds an awful lot like the Harry Potter series, too, and probably others that fantasy readers can think of.)

I recently read a book called How to Read Literature Like a Professor by Thomas C. Foster.  In it, he argues that there is only really one story.  Every story that exists relates to, references, and intertwines with every other story.  Authors often do this intentionally: making a character similar to a more familiar biblical or historical persona, setting up a plot that feels familiar for a reason, or even directly quoting or referencing an existing work.  Even unintentionally, stories reflect other stories.  Unless you are someone who has never ever read a book, heard a story, or watched a movie, you have internalized the tales of others.  This will come out in your writing.

I find myself needing a reminder of this from time to time, when I re-read a book series that has shaped my fiction.  Yes, there are parallels that can be drawn between my first novel and the work of Mercedes Lackey and Jacqueline Carey, among others.  It does not mean that my story is not original, or that my characters are simply re-imagined from theirs.  This is very far from the reality.  But they are both excellent female fantasy authors with strong female protagonists, and as I aspire to be the same, it should be no surprise that my book touches similar themes and approaches character development in a similar way.  It isn’t the same story; instead it is its own tale with occasional echoes of the stories of others. 

In the end, it’s all one story.

2 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. Jack
    Aug 25, 2010 @ 06:25:50

    Well, it makes sense that there is such a surprising correlation. Every story that exists is going to be a human creation, and there are only so many ways to document the human condition. Archetypes exist for a reason, they are tried and true methods for maintaining the interest of a target audience. If it wasn’t possible for people to relate to the characters, would they be reading the story at all?

    Reply

  2. Trackback: Finding Ideas « Butterflies and Dragons

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: